AppDepo Calculator Contact us Calculator
Shopping mallsApr 12, 2021·7 min read

What Google Play can tell you about a shopping mall's mobile app

In our previous piece, “A review of 10 shopping mall apps”, we looked at shopping mall apps in terms of visual appeal, content and ease of use. Now let us see what their Google Play listings can tell us.

Apptentive, a company specializing in online reputation management, found that 90% of users judge a mobile app by its rating on Google Play or the App Store. A further 79% of consumers check ratings and reviews before installing, and 55% look at ratings and reviews before making a transaction inside an app.

As a reminder, the study covers 10 mobile apps:

  1. 1MEGA
  2. 2Metropolis
  3. 3AFIMALL City
  4. 4Vodny
  5. 5Galeria
  6. 6Riviera
  7. 7Salaris
  8. 8Kashirskaya Plaza
  9. 9Columbus
  10. 10M5 Mall

We set out several criteria for assessing the apps:

  • The information on Google Play.
  • User reviews.

The first thing users look at when choosing an app on Google Play is the reviews, so let us start there.

User reviews

Most reviews are reports of one problem or another. One of the most common is a broken QR code scanner — almost every app in our review suffers from it. Problems with awarding points are close behind: some shoppers complain that points from a purchase take a day to appear, others that they simply vanish.

Yulia Shishkina, user of the Columbus app: — Out of 7! receipts today (all over 500 roubles) not a single one scanned! Four times the app offered to send a photo of the receipt to support, which we did. The rest of the time nothing happened at all! One of the last receipts was from Sportmaster for over 4,000 and I cannot even send it to support.

Another widespread problem is instability and a flaky internet connection. It affects the brightest — and, as it turns out, the heaviest — app in the group: MEGA.

Andrew Ivanov, user of the MEGA app: — Unbelievably slow. Maybe it is only like this on first launch, but there is no way to wait around for the second.

Natalia Andreeva, user of the MEGA app — The app HANGS!!! Does it even work? It says there is no internet connection. Why? The internet on my phone is flying.

All.H., user of the MEGA app: — The app is bright. But it is slow and there are a lot of updates. I have had it a couple of months and have already had to update it three times at least.

Remote parking payment raises plenty of questions. Some apps do not have it at all; in others it comes with serious difficulties. And yet this is precisely the feature mall visitors are most interested in.

Alexey Miroshchenko, user of the Metropolis app: — Paid for parking through the app. The money was taken, the payment was not registered. Had trouble at the exit. Pay for parking at the machine, the app is broken. When you enter card details you cannot copy and paste the number. Minimize the app and reopen it and it hangs — you have to quit and enter the payment details all over again.

Nikolay Telegin, user of the Afimall app: — Parking does not work on a Xiaomi Mi 8.

Even so, good reviews do turn up. The Afimall app, for instance, is praised for its convenient navigation, and MEGA for its bright design and services.

Vyacheslav Artemov, user of the Afimall app: — In my opinion this is the best app of its kind. Everything is simple and clear. The navigation is very convenient. Thank you to the developer for a splendid app.

Albina Aminova, user of the MEGA app: — Brilliant service — shopping without the bags! Very convenient! The app has a lot of information about discounts and promotions! Thank you to the developers!

Andreu Balcev, user of the Riviera app: — Not a bad app. Convenient filters, nice images. Runs fast, does not hang.

Let us look at a few more important indicators from Google Play:

  • how users rate the app
  • the date of the last update
  • the release notes
  • how reviews are handled

How users rate the app — the star rating

The rating is visible in the search results — the number next to the star — and then on the app's own page.

An app rating on Google Play

This figure often decides which app someone installs.

Here is how visitors themselves rate the mall apps in our selection:

  1. 1Riviera 4.9
  2. 2MEGA 4.4
  3. 3Kashirskaya Plaza 4.3
  4. 4AFIMALL City 4.2
  5. 5Vodny 3.6
  6. 6Galeria 3.3
  7. 7M5 Mall 3.0
  8. 8Columbus 2.6
  9. 9Metropolis 2.3
  10. 10Salaris 1.9

It stands to reason that a user trusts a highly rated app more and is therefore more motivated to install it.

Consumers found the Riviera app the most convenient and useful of all. It received the highest score and 87 reviews. Speaking of reviews: their number says a lot about how active an audience is and how willing it is to communicate. MEGA's visitors are by far the most engaged — 3,739 people have left reviews of the app on Google Play. That is orders of magnitude more than its nearest rivals, AFIMALL City with 823 reviews and Kashirskaya Plaza with 63.

Date of the last update

Regular updates make an app more reliable and stable, let the marketing team test new hypotheses, run A/B tests and adapt the interface to seasonal campaigns. In our own experience, an app needs to be updated at least once a quarter to do all that — and once a month is better.

The date of the last update is in the “Additional information” section at the bottom left of the app page, and sometimes at the top under “What's new”.

The update date on Google Play

The mall apps ranked by the date of their last update, according to Google Play:

  1. 1MEGA — January 18, 2021
  2. 2Riviera — January 14, 2021
  3. 3Metropolis — December 16, 2020
  4. 4Galeria — December 16, 2020
  5. 5AFIMALL City — December 7, 2020
  6. 6Kashirskaya Plaza — December 4, 2020
  7. 7M5 Mall — October 2, 2020
  8. 8Columbus — June 16, 2020
  9. 9Salaris — December 4, 2019
  10. 10Vodny — March 21, 2018

At an average of one update a year an app cannot be adapted to seasonal campaigns, and there is no way to run an A/B test in it either.

Release notes

One more detail worth paying attention to on Google Play is the release notes. This text is usually written by a technical specialist and is therefore full of dry facts and jargon. The only exception is MEGA:

“Yaaahoo! MEGA Friends is more than a loyalty program! Let's be friends. Are you with us? — At last, taking part in a webinar counts as attending an event for moving up the MEGA Friends levels — We've added great little pop-up hints — We've fixed a few small bugs. We keep at it :)”.

Here is a different example: the release notes for the new version of the Vodny app.

“Improvement for sending push messages: ru-RU”

The release notes in the Riviera app.

“Store search and display improved.”

Responding to reviews

Most of the 3,739 reviews left by users of the MEGA app are still unanswered. The most recent user question is dated January 14, 2021; the last reply from support was in 2019.

In the Vodny app, replies from the team behind it stopped even earlier — in 2018.

Comments are answered most often in the Kashirskaya Plaza app, where the most recent exchange is from December 2020.

By way of a conclusion

Of the 10 apps we looked at, only two are updated regularly and often enough: MEGA and Riviera.

For most of the apps the release notes fit into a single terse sentence.

The lion's share of reviews for every one of the 10 malls comes from unhappy users and, sadly, most comments go unanswered. Only Kashirskaya Plaza makes any attempt at a constructive dialogue.

Despite the sheer number of technical complaints from customers, almost a third of the apps hold a rating above 4 stars.

Work out the cost for your business
Build your set of modules in the calculator — from 10 000 ₽/mo
Share:

Read next

All articles

Tell us about your business

We will send a selection of modules and a cost estimate

+7 (495) 108-10-42
Thank you! We will be in touch shortly.

A modular platform for a mobile app and CRM

App Depo assembles a mobile app, a PWA, mini apps in Telegram and MAX and touchscreen kiosks from ready-made modules. Loyalty Program, Booking, online appointments, ordering and delivery, Check-in, Quests and Prize Draws are switched on separately — you pay only for what you use.

All customer data is collected in the CRM: profile, visits, purchases and bonuses. On that basis you segment the database, run push campaigns and see the results of your promotions in the analytics. You can work out the price of a set in the calculator.